Refinancing your mortgage in Ontario: when the penalty is worth paying
Refinancing pays off only if the savings or cash you gain outweigh the penalty and costs. Fixed-rate penalties are the greater of three months' interest or the interest rate differential, and lenders that compare against posted rates minus your original discount can charge several times more than lenders using their current rate.
Figures as of 2026-11-01.Worked examples use 4.12%, the Bank of Canada's average effective rate on new insured 5-year-plus fixed mortgages (2026-08), and are recalculated by our engine whenever rules or rates change.

Why refinance
Refinancing replaces your mortgage before or at renewal, usually to borrow more (debt consolidation, renovation), to change the amortization, or to get a lower rate. In Ontario you can typically borrow up to 80% of your home's value on a refinance; mortgage insurance isn't available for refinances, and the stress test applies to the new loan.
The penalty decides whether it pays
Breaking a fixed-rate mortgage early costs the greater of three months' interest or the interest rate differential (IRD). Your lender must tell you how it calculates the IRD, and the method makes a big difference.
| Method | Comparison rate | Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Three months' interest | — | $5,850 |
| IRD, your lender's current rate | 4.12% | $14,580 |
| IRD, posted rate minus your 1.80-point discount | 4.25% | $12,825 |
The posted-rate example uses the Bank of Canada's posted 3-year rate (6.05%, 2026-11-04) less a 1.80-point original discount. If refinancing to 4.12% saves about $264 a month on the same balance and remaining amortization, the $14,580 penalty takes about 56 months to earn back, before legal and appraisal costs.
Source: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Mortgage fees: prepayment penalties, effective October 15, 2025. Checked .Before you sign your next mortgage
The penalty method is set when you sign, not when you break. Two offers at the same rate can cost very differently if you might break: with a $500,000 mortgage broken after 30 months when rates have fallen a point, the lender using its own current rate charges about $11,743; one using posted rates minus your discount charges about $13,387.
Alternatives to a full refinance
- Blend and extend: some lenders blend your current rate with today's into a new term, avoiding the penalty.
- A HELOC or second mortgage: borrow against equity without breaking the first mortgage; see HELOCCalculator.ca and SecondMortgageCalculator.ca.
- Wait for renewal: at the end of the term you can change lender or amount with no penalty.
How much equity you can borrow
Lenders cap a refinance at 80% of the appraised value. On a $900,000 home with $400,000 owing, that's a mortgage of up to $720,000, so up to $320,000 of new money before costs and any penalty. The appraisal sets the value, not your estimate, and the stress test applies to the whole new loan: at 4.12% you'd qualify at 6.12%, with your income, debts and property tax inside the lender's debt-service limits.
Consolidating debt into the mortgage
Moving $30,000 of credit-card debt at a typical 19.99% into a mortgage at 4.12% cuts the monthly interest from about $500 to about $102. But spread over 25 years, the same $30,000 costs about $17,929 in mortgage interest. The saving is real only if you pay that part down fast, for example with the prepayment privileges the amortization guide describes, and don't run the cards back up.
Costs beyond the penalty
- A lawyer to register the new mortgage and discharge the old one (our purchase estimate is $2,000 for fees and disbursements; a refinance is often less).
- Registration of the new charge: $86.42 in Ontario from November 2, 2026.
- An appraisal, and a discharge fee on the old mortgage; some lenders pay part of these to win the business.
When waiting for renewal is cheaper
Compare the penalty and costs with the interest you'd save before the term would have ended anyway. In the example above, saving about $264 a month for the remaining 36 months is worth about $9,511, against a $14,580 penalty before legal and appraisal costs. If the saving doesn't clearly beat the cost, a HELOC or a blend may get you the money now, and the rate can wait for renewal, when switching is free of penalty.
$400,000 owing, signed when the lender's posted rate was 6.79%, so the original discount was 1.59 points.
| Balance / contract rate | $400,000 / 5.20% |
|---|---|
| Months left in the term | 30 |
| New rate | 4.12% |
| Three months' interest | $5,200 |
| Posted-rate interest rate differential | $7,400comparison rate 4.46% |
| Penalty (the greater) | $7,400 |
| Interest saved over the 30 months | $10,438 |
| Breaking saves | $3,038before legal and appraisal costs |
Open the new mortgage in the payment calculator →Computed November 1, 2026.
What this means for you
Ask your lender for a written penalty quote before anything else, and ask which method it uses: posted rate minus your discount, or its current rate. Then compare the penalty with the interest you'd save over the months left in your term, not over the whole amortization.
If you need cash rather than a lower rate, compare a refinance with a home equity line of credit at HELOCCalculator.ca; for whether breaking is worth it after a revaluation, see ReValued.ca.
Frequently asked questions
How is a mortgage prepayment penalty calculated?
For fixed rates, usually the greater of three months' interest or the interest rate differential. Your lender must explain its method, and federally regulated lenders publish penalty calculators.
How much can I refinance in Ontario?
Lenders commonly allow up to 80% of the home's value on a refinance, which cannot be insured. The new loan must pass the stress test.
Primary sources
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada — Mortgage fees: prepayment penalties (effective October 15, 2025). Checked .
- Justice Laws — Financial Consumer Protection Framework Regulations (SOR/2021-181), ss. 38–46. Checked .
- OSFI — Minimum qualifying rate for uninsured mortgages (Guideline B-20). Checked .